About the Post

Author Information

I am a public health doctor who is cynically optimistic about most things.

Book review: Saddam City

Amidst the turmoil of post-war Iraq, it’s unsurprising that many chose not to mull over the demise of the previous regime as real and present challenges they faced quickly put pay to any initial euphoria. However given the duration and barbarity of Saddam’s rule it is surprising that there have been few books that have effectively articulated its horrors throughout the years.

In contrast to the mediocre propaganda they spew out, totalitarian regimes seem to spur some of the best literary works in those resisting them, be it the Soviet Union for Solzhenitsyn  and Nabakov or the rise of European fascism for Kafka.

Saddam City by Mahmoud Saeed is a definite contribution in this regard and reading through, it is uncanny how similar it reads to the above-mentioned writers. The macabre absurdities generated by such systems seem to yield close parallels despite vast contextual differences that separate them.

Saeed’s story is about an Iraqi teacher from Basra who is one day whisked into the brutal world of the Iraqi Emin, shuttled from prison to prison with no idea of the case against him. Effortlessly shifting from the mundane to the harrowing, the tale is spun in such a matter-of-fact way as to reflect the brutal but cold arbitrariness of the regime.

To give him credit, Saeed does not attempt to capitalise on the graphic aspects of his and other prisoners’ ordeals, but still manages to shock and unsettle to reader. The protagonist’s journey across Iraq reveals the breadth of the regime’s destruction as he finds tremendous warmth from amongst the very many facets of Iraq’s populous united in their common brutalising ordeal. Rather an optimistic take given the post-regime aftermath.

A former prisoner and schoolteacher himself, the autobiographical nature of this work is taken for granted and its original Arabic title was in fact I am the One Who Saw but published by Dar Al-Saqi in London under the title of Saddam City. A short but engaging read, this work is a worthy attempt at doing justice to the very many victims of the Saddam era.

3 Comments on “Book review: Saddam City”

  1. Sand Storm December 1, 2010 at 7:36 pm #

    Readings about Sadam’s era are need more than they are available today.

    Today the propaganda against the new Iraq is so massive that the opinion of many is now that in Sadam’s era the situation was much better.

  2. Shkara December 5, 2010 at 9:12 am #

    Thanks for bringing this to our attention Ali, looks like a book worth reading. It’ll be quite interesting to see the similarities in perception/writing to other survivors and witnesses to totalitarian regimes such as Solzhenitsyn as you describe.

  3. Mahmoud saeed December 17, 2010 at 9:52 pm #

    السيد علي لطيف المحترم
    قرأت تعليقك على روايتي “أنا الذي رأى” والتي ترجمت باسم صدام سيتي بالرغم مني
    أشكرك جزيل الشكر وأحبّ أن أوضح شيئاً مهماً وهو أنني عندما خرجت تركت العراق سنة 1981 بعد خروجي من السجن لم أجد ناشرا في الأردن وفي سوريا وعدت بنشرها لكن الرقابة حذفت منها فصلين ثم لم تنشرها

    تحياتي القلبية
    دمت
    محمود سعيد

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: